Skip links

Remote work from abroad and permanent establishment: the new OECD Commentary on Article 5

Pietro Cumpostu, Dottore Commercialista (Italian Chartered Accountant)Updated

Work performed on a settled basis from the home or from another place situated in a State other than that of the enterprise raises the question whether that place constitutes a permanent establishment of the enterprise in the State where it is located. With the 2025 Update to the Model Tax Convention, the OECD Council adopted in the Commentary on Article 5 a specific interpretive framework, which combines a working-time threshold with a check of a commercial reason for the person's presence in that State.

The 2025 Update to the OECD Model

The 2025 Update to the OECD Model Tax Convention was approved by the Committee on Fiscal Affairs on 13 October 2025 and adopted by the OECD Council at its 1502nd session on 18 November 2025 (C(2025)159), as indicated in the document and in the related publication page. The OECD announced it in the press release of 19 November 2025 and on 30 September 2026 published the 2025 full version of the Model, which sets out the articles and commentaries in the text in force as at 18 November 2025.

In the Commentary on Article 5 the former paragraphs 18 and 19 are deleted and the new paragraphs 44.1 to 44.21 are introduced, dealing with cross-border work from the home or from another «relevant place» (other relevant place): a second home, holiday accommodation, the home of a family member or of an acquaintance, provided it is not premises of the enterprise or of an enterprise connected to it by contractual or other relationships, such as a customer, a supplier or an associated enterprise (para. 44.1).

The Commentary is not a domestic rule. It is an instrument for the interpretation of double tax treaties that follow the Model and does not bind the court; the outcome of each case also depends on the text of the applicable treaty.

The general conditions recalled by the Commentary

The new paragraphs start from the ordinary requirements of a fixed place of business. The existence of a permanent establishment is to be established on the basis of the facts and circumstances of each period (para. 44.3); the place must have a certain degree of permanence (para. 44.4); activities of a preparatory or auxiliary character remain excluded under paragraph 4 of Article 5 (para. 44.5).

The Commentary also states that the mere fact that a person, for example an employee, carries on at a place activities connected with the enterprise does not automatically mean that that place is a place of business of the enterprise (para. 44.6). Intermittent or occasional use is not sufficient; continuous use for an extended period may instead be an indication of it (para. 44.7).

First stage: the 50% working-time threshold

According to paragraph 44.8, the home or the other relevant place is generally not considered a place of business of the enterprise if the person has worked there for less than 50% of his or her total working time for that enterprise, over any twelve-month period beginning or ending in the tax period concerned. The Commentary adds that exceptions to this criterion are not expected in most situations.

The threshold is not an automatic exemption. The word «generally» leaves room for facts and circumstances pointing the other way, and the calculation of working time is based on the person's actual conduct: contractual arrangements and company policies on agile work (lavoro agile) are useful only to the extent that they correspond to what happens in practice (para. 44.9).

Second stage: the commercial reason

If the person works from the home or from the other place for at least 50% of working time over twelve months, whether there is a place of business is determined on the basis of facts and circumstances (para. 44.10). A relevant factor is the existence of a commercial reason for carrying on the activity in that State, which is present when the person's physical presence facilitates the carrying on of the enterprise's activity, for example because persons or resources to which the enterprise must have access are located there (para. 44.11). According to paragraph 44.12, a commercial reason is present when the person interacts directly with customers, suppliers, associated enterprises or other persons on behalf of the enterprise and that interaction is facilitated by his or her location in that State.

Paragraph 44.17 lists, by way of example, activities that may amount to a commercial reason when they are facilitated by presence in that State:

  • meetings with the enterprise's customers;
  • development of new customers or identification of business opportunities;
  • identification of new suppliers and management of relations and contracts with suppliers;
  • real-time, or near real-time, interaction with customers or suppliers in different time zones;
  • access to expertise relevant to the activity, such as regular meetings with a university that carries out research useful to the enterprise;
  • collaboration with other enterprises;
  • services for customers of that State that require physical presence, such as training or repairs at the customer's premises;
  • interaction with employees and other personnel of the enterprise or of associated enterprises.

Intermittent or occasional interaction, such as brief occasional visits to a customer, is not sufficient (para. 44.14). If more than one reason justifies work from that place, it is enough that one of them is a commercial reason (para. 44.13).

What does not constitute a commercial reason

The Commentary excludes a commercial reason when the enterprise allows work from the home or from another place solely in order to obtain or retain the person's services (para. 44.15) or solely in order to reduce costs, for example office expenditure (para. 44.16). The mere presence in the State of customers, suppliers or of an associated enterprise, as well as the mere fact that the place is in a different time zone from that of the State of the enterprise, does not automatically lead to the conclusion that a commercial reason exists (para. 44.18). In the absence of a commercial reason, the place is not a place of business of the enterprise, unless other facts and circumstances indicate otherwise (para. 44.19).

A person who alone conducts the activity of the enterprise

Different considerations apply when the person is the only or the principal person who conducts the activity of the enterprise. Paragraph 44.20 gives as an example the non-resident consultant who, for an extended period, carries on from his or her home in a State most of the activity of his or her consulting business: in that case the home constitutes a place of business of the enterprise.

The Commentary's examples

Paragraph 44.21 illustrates the criteria with five examples, always to be applied in relation to the facts of the individual case:

  • example A: three consecutive months of work from a place rented in another State, after a holiday, in a twelve-month period: the place is not «fixed» for lack of permanence; the conclusion does not change if the stay depends on other personal reasons, such as caring for a family member;
  • example B: work from the home in the other State one or two days a week throughout the year, equal to 30% of working time: the place is fixed, but, unless facts point the other way, it is not a place of business of the enterprise;
  • example C: work from the home for 80% of the time, with regular visits to local customers to provide them with services: there is a commercial reason and, unless facts point the other way, the home constitutes a permanent establishment;
  • example D: work from the home for 60% of the time, with services rendered remotely to customers in several States and a quarterly visit to a local customer: the mere presence of customers in the State and intermittent visits do not amount to a commercial reason;
  • example E: almost exclusive work from the home in order to provide real-time support to customers located in different time zones: presence in that State facilitates the enterprise's services and, unless facts point the other way, the home constitutes a permanent establishment.

Positions of the States

Italy has not entered observations on the new paragraphs 44.1 to 44.21; its observation no. 181 on the Commentary on Article 5 concerns other paragraphs. Several States depart from them in whole or in part. Among member countries, Israel has entered observations on the method of calculating the 50% threshold, on the relevance of a group of employees, of essential activities and of the home of founders or senior managers, and on example D; the Czech Republic reserves the right not to apply the specific criteria of paragraphs 44.1-44.21 and Chile does not adhere to paragraphs 44.6-44.21 (observations nos. 220-226 on the Commentary on Article 5). Among non-member countries, India does not share the time-threshold and commercial-reason conditions (position no. 55), Nigeria does not share the interpretation of paragraphs 44.14, 44.15 and 44.16 and the conclusion of example D, and Malaysia reserves the right to agree bilaterally a percentage different from that in paragraph 44.8 (positions nos. 58-61 on Article 5). These positions indicate that the new Commentary is not followed uniformly and that, for each State, the applicable treaty and the approach of the foreign administration need to be checked.

Domestic law: Article 162 TUIR and Article 183 of Legislative Decree 117/2026

For the purposes of income taxes and IRAP, Article 162 TUIR defines a permanent establishment as a fixed place of business through which the non-resident enterprise carries on in whole or in part its activity in the territory of the State (paragraph 1), lists typical cases, such as a place of management, a branch and an office (paragraph 2), excludes activities of a preparatory or auxiliary character (paragraphs 4 and 4-bis, with the anti-fragmentation rule in paragraph 5) and governs, in paragraph 6, a permanent establishment constituted by a person who acts on behalf of the enterprise and, in paragraph 7, the exclusion for an independent agent. The provision contains no specific rules on remote work or work from the home.

From 1 January 2027 the rules are contained in Article 183 of Legislative Decree 117 of 19 June 2026, «Permanent establishment», whose heading refers to Article 162 TUIR; in the new numbering the person who acts on behalf of the enterprise is governed by paragraph 7 and the independent agent by paragraph 8. The new text likewise contains no references to agile work or to the staff member's home. The applicable text is to be identified by reference to the tax period concerned.

The personal permanent establishment

The Commentary's test concerns the fixed place of business and does not exhaust the inquiry. A permanent establishment may also exist when a person, in the State in which he or she works, acts on behalf of the enterprise and habitually concludes contracts, or plays a role leading to their conclusion, without material modification by the enterprise, under paragraph 5 of Article 5 of the Model and Article 162(6) TUIR (from 2027, Article 183(7) of Legislative Decree 117/2026). This case does not depend on the 50% threshold or on the commercial reason: for commercial roles that work from abroad, the definition of negotiation and signing powers therefore requires a separate examination, on the basis of the applicable treaty.

Italian administrative practice and case law

As at 9 November 2026 there are no circulars or replies to ruling requests of the Revenue Agency on whether a permanent establishment arises as a result of work from staff members' homes. The Agency's rulings on agile work performed from Italy for foreign employers, such as ruling no. 626 of 27 September 2021, concern the taxation of the employee's income and not the position of the enterprise. There are also no decisions of the Supreme Court (Corte di cassazione), in the public archive that can be consulted, on the relationship between agile work or telework and a permanent establishment.

In the absence of domestic guidance, the Commentary orients the interpretation of treaties that follow the Model without binding the tax administration or the court.

Effects for the enterprise and for the worker

For an Italian enterprise with staff working from abroad, the existence of a permanent establishment in the other State entails, under the legislation of that State and the treaty, the attribution to that permanent establishment of a part of the income and the related local obligations.

For a foreign enterprise with staff working from Italy, a permanent establishment in Italy entails subjection to IRES and IRAP of the income attributable to it, as well as filing obligations and, where the conditions are met, withholding-agent obligations.

The taxation of the worker's income is a distinct question. Under Article 23(1)(c) TUIR, income from employment performed in the territory of the State is treated as produced there in relation to non-residents; in the treaties the allocation is governed by Article 15 of the Model. The worker's tax residence and social security require a separate check and are not dealt with here.

Elements to be examined in the individual case

The assessment requires, in short:

  • a survey of the staff who work from another State, with an indication of the State and of the share of working time on a rolling twelve-month basis, established on actual presence and not only on agile-work arrangements;
  • for those who reach or exceed 50%, documentation of the reasons for the choice (personal needs, retention of the relationship, cost containment) and a check that the activity is not directed at customers, suppliers or other persons of the State in which the person is located, in the terms of paragraphs 44.11-44.18;
  • a check of the powers to negotiate and conclude contracts, for the purposes of a personal permanent establishment;
  • examination of the applicable treaty and of the positions expressed by the other State on the Commentary;
  • separate handling of the aspects relating to taxes on the worker's income and to social security.

Dedicated FAQ

Other guides

Sources verified as at 9 November 2026.

↑ Back to contents

This website uses cookies to improve your web experience.